Who Should Mourn for Long Island College Hospital?

The former campus of Long Island College Hospital (Isabelle Muge Niu/ NYCityLens)

The former campus of Long Island College Hospital (Isabelle Muge Niu/ NYCityLens)

Stas Reznik sat in front of his apartment building in Cobble Hill, Brooklyn, sneering at the large poster on the closed hospital across the street that read “The Children’s Hospital of Downstate—Long Island College Hospital.”

“You’d think they’d have taken down the poster,” said Reznik, a photographer who has lived across from Long Island College Hospital (LICH) for 14 years. In just the course of a year, he watched the 156-year-old hospital turn from a bustling full-service medical facility to an emergency room in an otherwise empty building, Reznik said. He has lost almost all his neighbors, including the doctors in residence and staff who used to occupy the buildings next door.

Reznik is among hundreds of people affected by the closing of LICH, the latest of a series of New York hospitals to close in recent years. Some impacts on the community are immediate. Since the hospital ceased its inpatient service on May 22, hundreds of former staff have lost their jobs, more than 20 specialists have left the area and small business owners who used to rely on the hospital for customers are struggling to keep their doors open. But closing the 506-bed hospital also has a borough-wide and even citywide effect, said Alan Sager, professor at the Boston University School of Public Health.

“People might look at New York and say there are enough beds, but they are not in the right places,” Sager said. “They are in Manhattan. You have so many people in Brooklyn but there are not as many beds.”

Brooklyn only has 13 of the 26 hospitals it had in the 1980s and now the borough of 2.5 million people has a bed-to-population ratio below the national average, Department of Health data show. “If more hospitals close in Brooklyn, we would see a large medical desert,” he said.

The loss of scarce medical resources is especially risky for the elderly and the low-income populations, who typically have more urgent healthcare needs, said Mireille Jacobson, the director of the Center for Health Care Management and Policy at University of California-Irvine.

“Having a hospital close by is essential in case of emergencies,” Jacobson said. “We found when the distance to the nearest hospital increased, death from heart attacks went up.”

About 12,000 of residents within a one-mile radius of LICH are older than 60, according to 2010 census data. Besides, LICH was the closest hospital to the neighborhood of Red Hook, where the majority of the population lives in public housing projects.

The Health Resources and Services Administration labeled Red Hook as a “medically underserved area,” a designation given to areas with too few primary care providers, high infant mortality and high poverty.

“It’s a very scary situation,” Khadijah James, a former emergency medical technician and long-time Red Hook resident, said while waiting for a bus to take her to the New York Methodist Hospital in Park Slope. She was going to to visit her sister. “I don’t know why they closed it (LICH). It was a good hospital and we used to walk there.”

The closing of LICH increases driving distance to nearest hospitals. (Distance Matters Report, Office of Public Advocate 2013)

The closing of LICH increases driving distance to nearest hospitals. (Distance Matters Report, Office of Public Advocate 2013)

The two closest hospitals—New York Methodist Hospital and Brooklyn Hospital Center in Fort Greene—have also been under stress since LICH stopped accepting ambulances to its emergency room. Many of its former patients have been transferred to their emergency rooms.

Both hospitals have seen increases in the number of patients to their emergency rooms, which already suffer from long waiting times, data from New York State Department of Health show. The agency rates both Methodist and Brooklyn Hospital Center as “poor performers” in emergency department timeliness. Methodist’s ER patients wait on average for 66 minutes to be seen by a professional while those of Brooklyn Hospital Center wait for 114 minutes, compared to the national average of 26 minutes, the data show.

But given time, both institutions may be able to adjust to the new normal, just like those near St. Vincent’s Hospital did after the Manhattan facility closed in 2010, said Amesh Adalja, senior associate at the University of Pittsburgh Medical Center.

“What we found was many hospitals used innovative strategies to expand capacity and became more efficient,” Adaljia said. To meet the demand, some hospitals created new operating rooms, some increased staffing or found ways to discharge patients faster. “But you can only do so much, the hospitals are restrained by their physical layout.”

Lyn Hill, vice president for Communications at New York Methodist Hospital, said the institution has been able to absorb extra patients in its emergency room.

Jeanette Haslett, an emergency department doctor at Brooklyn Hospital Center, said the hospital implemented many changes to accommodate the influx of former LICH patients, such as rearranging the ER room to use formerly vacant space and purchasing reclining treatment chairs that serve as temporary beds.

“We are trying to do the best we can and put chairs where we can,” she said, pointing to the small space next to the door occupied by a treatment chair. The hospital has in fact managed to reduce waiting time through these measures, she said, but winter will pose new challenges. “We will get the true patient flow then,” Haslett said.

Thrive or Die

Hospitals are not the only ones bracing for a difficult winter, so are some small businesses close to the former hospital site.

“We are losing a lot of customers that we have known for a long time, workers at the hospital from janitors to nurses to people who work in administration at LICH,” said Saad Almondaser, manager of Champion Deli on Atlantic Street. One fourth of his business vanished after the hospital closed, he said, so his store relies on visitors to the nearby Brooklyn Bridge Park and a few remaining nurses at the emergency room.

But the nurses may leave any time and visitors are unsustainable once the cold weather kicks in. “In the winter nobody is going to go to the park so it’s going to be dead,” he said. “We are trying to figure out how we can manage to get through the winter.”

Across the street from Almondaser’s store, Shoukat Ali was counting the days till he permanently shuts the door on Crown Deli, his home and livelihood for the past 24 years.

The small shop on the corner of Atlantic Avenue and Hicks Street thrived with LICH but now it will die with LICH, he said. Ali kept the shop running during the legal battles over LICH, in hopes that it would remain intact. But after losing more than $35,000, he decided to close the shop this month.

“I don’t know how long it will take for the new buildings to go up, but I can’t wait, I’m losing money,” Ali said.

Although many nearby merchants said they felt some impact of LICH’s closure, none took a toll as big as Ali’s. Nurses and janitors at LICH were never the main clientele for the diners, bars and boutiques near the hospital, the owners said. Their main business comes from the local residents in Cobble Hill, whose median household income was nearly $40,000 higher than that of New York in 2011, according to city-data.com.

This is why when Simon Karapetyan took over a deli near LICH this February, he took the advice from a friend working in the neighborhood to make the place “classier” and attract local residents. Karapetyan replaced $1 soft drinks with locally roasted coffee, redesigned the space to add a bookshelf to the blackboard wall. Within a few months, residents say the Cobble Hill Canteen became a favorite neighborhood coffee shop.

But for Rezenik, LICH has become more than a healthcare provider during his 14 years of being its neighbor. It has become an entity that holds the community together, he said.

“I know people who were born there and had their kids there,” Reznik said. “It’s a family and now the family has been ripped apart.”


8 Responses to "Who Should Mourn for Long Island College Hospital?"

  1. Bk  October 21, 2014 at 6:21 pm

    No mention of Red Hook resident mr Cruz who died due to delayed ambulance response just days after lich was closed & its ambulances stopped running. But that’s the impact on this community when a nursing are room replaced a hospital & real emergency room. Lives lost.

  2. Bk  October 21, 2014 at 6:25 pm

    Correction: The impact on a community when a hospital & real emergency room are shut down & replaced by an urgent care walk in clinic. Lives lost

  3. Thomas H. Harris  October 22, 2014 at 1:07 pm

    Express your anger this Sunday, October 26 at 1:00pm and come march with us at our Last Ditch(?) to Save LICH and it begins on the corner of Atlantic Ave. and Nevins St. PLEASE come and bring as many people as you can. We seriously need a HUGE crowd.

    Please let everyone know they’re more than invited to come.

    The Sunday March on Atlantic Avenue to protest the proposed closing of LICH and sale to Fortis is planned for October 26 at 1:00 pm. It will start at Nevins Street and Atlantic Ave and proceed down Atlantic Avenue and will build to conclude at Hicks Street and Atlantic Avenue: to Long Island College Hospital. Local and regional community members, politicians, firefighters, EMS workers, police, nurses, doctors, teachers and their students, congregants, local merchants and everyone interested in maintaining full-service emergency healthcare are welcome to participate. Come and join in the music, singing and shouting for justice. The goal is to put pressure on Governor Cuomo, the NY State Comptroller, and the NY State Attorney General to reverse this decision and to save our hospital. Rain or Shine.

    Long Island College Hospital, which has served the communities of Williamsburg, Dumbo, Brooklyn Hts, Cobble Hill, Carroll Gardens and Red Hook for 150 years, is on the brink of being sold to Fortis Real Estate Company and turned into luxury condos; with a medical facility being called an emergency room but which is really only an urgicare center being run by NYU. The other area ERs at Brooklyn, Methodist, Lutheran and Maimonides Hospitals are today overrun and failing since the closing of the Long Island College Hospital Emergency Room which saw 60,000 patients each year. These hospitals serve 1.5 million Brooklynites. Exploding local populations, residential, commercial and tourist make closing LICH obscene and indefensible.

    Come and join in the music, singing and shouting for justice.
    Join the Sunday March on Atlantic Avenue to protest the proposed closing of LICH and sale to Fortis: Sunday, October 26 at 1:00 pm, starting at Nevins Street and going to Hicks Street and Long Island College Hospital. Rain or Shine.

    Thank you all very, very much.

    LICH Forever!!

  4. Brooklyn votes.  October 22, 2014 at 1:59 pm

    Gov. Cuomo has assaulted Brooklyn in this with 2000 jobs lost? You’d think Astorino would visit this issue? a vital hospital that was managed into the ground by the SUNY system the community depended on (not billing? not filing for reimbursements?) NO CARE NOR CONCERN with lives in the balance? a cadre of black-shirted security guard appear and block ambulances and remove patients in wee hours — and defiance of court orders across an entire summer is lost on NY Times and other media supposedly objective? The people beleived Mayor DeBlasio would help or were led to believe that by his rhetoric — and where did that leave us? Back to Cuomo avoiding the issue AND our areas of Brooklyn, entirely… Where is Astorino?

    • Thomas H. Harris  October 22, 2014 at 4:03 pm

      Astorino is running his campaign on very little money, while Cuomo has gobs of it, and, as we all very well know, he who has all the money owns the debate, as well as the airtime to broadcast it.

      THAT’S where Astorino is.

      BTW, I found out that Cuomo and Astorino will be debating live this evening from Buffalo. I don’t know what channel here in NYC will be broadcasting it, probably Thirteen.

      • PMG  October 25, 2014 at 8:14 pm

        Where is Astorino?? Are you kidding me?? Who cares! I seriously doubt Astorino gives two cents about LICH, but even if he did come around, remember-HE IS RUNNING FOR OFFICE! Think about the last politician who ran for office and showed solidarity with LICH. Last thing I heard from him about the subject, he was joining in the chorus of Downstaters expressing “doubt” that the California company first chosen to buy LICH was not able fulfill the agreement to run a full service hospital (I still don’t know what that was about). It’s politicians that got LICH into this mess, but it’s not going to be a politician to get LICH out of it (God willing).

  5. Brenda Pepper  October 23, 2014 at 9:32 am

    Thank you all and will see you at the March. Get out your markers and get a piece of poster board. Make a poster that gets out your frustrations. Lets make this a huge parade and Rally. We are looking for drummers and horn players to lead the March down Atlantic Ave. Also if anyone has a cardboard coffin for the march and would be willing to get a group togetherto carry it dressed in black, to show possible deaths in hospital from the clousure. Maybe find musician to play When the saints go marching in.

  6. Maik Obermuller  October 23, 2014 at 10:18 am

    It would be great if we had a hospital every quarter mile, a park every couple of blocks, affordable housing all through out NYC, No one needing to be homeless, no hungry, no poor, unemployment at less 1%, no discrimination, no issues with the police, no problems with the environment,

    LICH was a hospital that lost money for 19 years, was about 500 million in the red. Most hospitals are loosing money today but not at that level. The unions did not step up and say “oh we will help by reducing salaries and benefits.” The top administrators did not help by reducing their salaries. The community did not help by using LICH as their primary hospital.

    SUNY which is designed to be a university system tried to get into the hospital business which was a failure. SUNY needs to stay with education. The fiscal drain on SUNY is incredible with the LICH losses. Every SUNY in NYS may have to come up with some of their own excess cash reserves to help pay off the LICH debt even after it is fully sold.

    That may force tuition raises for the least capable of affording this (students).

    In an ideal world a white night would ride in and take on LICH losses and keep it open. This is a real world where a great majority are still feeling the affects of a recession.

    The LICH activist have made up false facts to defend their hospital. Even now that SUNY has finalized the sale to Fortis and money has exchanged hands. Still the LICH activist make up lies and try to open a past that no longer exists.

    Mr Cruz died under unfortunate circumstances. Trying to tie his death to LICH closing is ugly lie. SUNY is NOT going to run LICH anymore! NYS does not want anything to do with LICH. DeBlasio wants nothing to do with LICH.

    It is time to make your peace and work with Fortis and NYU to make what health care is able to be offered be valuable to the community.

Comments are closed.